Church of San Pietro Extra Moenia in Spoleto

Church of San Pietro Extra Moenia in Spoleto

Not far from the historical centre of Spoleto, at the confluence of the SS3 Flaminia and the road to Monteluco, stands the Romanesque church of San Pietro, one of the most important in Umbria for its architectural layout and decorative richness.

The primitive building was probably erected by Spoleto’s bishop Achilleo at the beginning of the 5th century; the church, perhaps Spoleto’s first cathedral, was used as a burial place for the city’s bishops. The cemetery use of the area, which is very ancient, is evidenced by a number of 5th-6th century burials found during excavation campaigns and the numerous reused materials found especially near the rectory cloister. In Roman times, there were several buildings of considerable importance beneath the church.

Inside, in addition to a series of marble tombstones from different eras, are the remains of important bishops, such as that of Antimo Martire who died in 176, those transferred from the church of St. Eufemia of Giovanni II, martyred by Totila’s Goths presumably in 546, and bishop Pietro, in office during the creation of the Longobard Duchy and until 594.

The church was entirely rebuilt in the Romanesque period.

The façade

Probably built around 1180, it is an unicum in its architectural layout and sculptural organisation. At the end of the 17th century, it underwent interventions in the side fields and tympanum, which are in fact plastered and not stone.

In the upper register are the statues of St. Peter and St. Andrew, separated from the lower registers by three rose windows, the central one with animals symbolising the four Evangelists in the corners, reminiscent of the one in the famous Cathedral of Spoleto.

In the lower register are three portals between which are beautiful bas-reliefs with racemes, figures and animals representing an iconographic programme consisting of numerous panels with sculptures of exceptional quality, depicting scenes from the life of the Apostle Peter, and episodes from medieval bestiaries and fables.

Starting from the left, numerous scenes of moralistic intent are sculpted, such as the Death of the Just and the Death of the Sinner, followed by scenes featuring the lion, a metaphor for human superiority over the devil.

The scene with the fox and the crows is inspired by a fable where the protagonist, symbolising the devil and sin, pretends to be dead to lure the unsuspecting birds to her before devouring them.

The last two scenes are those of the student wolf and the ram, also inspired by a fable by Marie de France, a zoomorphic version of the italian idiom “l’abito non fa il monaco” (the dress does not make the monk), and finally the lion and the dragon, symbolising God and the devil respectively.

The Interior

The interior of the church, half-hidden by 17th-century intervention, was rebuilt in 1329, following a fire that had devastated it during a war. The church has three apsidal naves in Roman Baroque style, with pillars supporting round arches, surmounted by an elliptical dome.

The frescoes that once dominated the walls are only partially preserved: on the right counter façade there are a few fragments that are difficult to read, while on the left one there is a depiction of the Eternal, with two bishop saints and the patron at the bottom, dated to the late 15th-early 16th century. Numerous paintings, mostly dating back to the 16th century, are kept at the altars.

In the first niche of the left aisle, there is also a finely carved marble baptistery from 1487, while in both side aisles, at the height of the first pillar, there are two holy water stoups. Finally, in the left transept there is a wooden Crucifix dating back to the late 15th-early 16th century.

Did you know?
The Dark Side of Romanesque Art: Demons, Nightmares and Sin on the Façade of San Pietro in Spoleto

On the façade of the Basilica of San Pietro in Spoleto, hidden among the intricate details of one of the most fascinating sculptural cycles of Romanesque Umbria, lies a teratological narrative that few visitors notice. The stone panels do not simply tell the story of the apostle; they also reveal the changing face of Evil, which appears here in three distinct forms, almost like a catalogue of medieval obsessions.

The first two panels of the portal, usually interpreted as episodes from the life of Saint Peter, actually conceal an extraordinary iconographic subtext. In them, the devil is never depicted in the same way. The first panel shows a defeated demon, crouching beneath the weight of Peter’s key and the Archangel Michael: a hairy creature with grasping fingers, which the tradition of the Physiologus associated with the monkey, figura diaboli. It is the defeat of deception, evil that crawls and bends beneath its burden.

The Triumph of the Demons.

In the second panel, the narrative becomes more disturbing and unfolds in three simultaneous scenes. On the left, a sinner is hurled headfirst into the mouth of Hell, a sort of boiling cauldron that swallows its prey: the demons have already carried out their justice. In the centre, a second deathbed scene: a woman with flaming hair and tightly bound wrists awaits her fate. And this is where the panel reveals its most striking surprise. The woman is not alone. Two demons attack her simultaneously. The first, with a curved tail, crescent-shaped horns and cloven hooves, is a satyr, a faun who grabs the victim by the hair in a grotesque, dancing movement. The second, meanwhile, sits astride the dying woman's body, pressing down on her abdomen. It is the nightmare, the incubus that patristic tradition—from Augustine to Isidore of Seville, from Gregory the Great to Gervase of Tilbury—described as a lustful woodland spirit, given to tormenting sleepers and joining with women in an unholy union. The Archangel Michael, on the right, turns away. His gesture is clear: he chooses not to intervene. Damnation is certain.

Why a woman? Because medieval theology, from Augustine onwards, considered women more vulnerable to the devil and more susceptible to the sin of lust. The choice of a female figure is therefore no coincidence: it conveys a warning, a cautionary message addressed to the viewer. The fact that the woman is already bound to her deathbed—the restraints holding her in place—recalls the role of chains in the life of Saint Peter, but perhaps also suggests an etymological play on the words incubus and vinculum, oppression and bondage.

Unfortunately, the inscription held by the demon on a scroll is missing. It may have read 'Dolco quia non est meus' (“I grieve because she is not mine”), or perhaps 'Dolco quia ante erat meus' (“I grieve because she once was mine”). Two interpretations, two destinies. The stone remains silent, and the image stands there, telling on its own one of the darkest and most fascinating stories of Umbrian Romanesque art.

The sculptures of San Pietro are not merely a masterpiece of style, but a place where Romanesque art reveals its darkest face, and where the attentive traveller can still glimpse, in the stone, the echoes of ancient fears.

Explore the surroundings
Main attractions in the vicinity